Reliquum est, silentium
posted by C. Briem at Wednesday, March 05, 2014
And to think the proposal of "consolidation" is almost a century old in these parts, if infographics are judged by how they impact change, we are going for the world record in longevity (or is 'retardation' more apt?). And to think in the last 100 years places like Phoenix, Las Vegas, Houston and Jacksonville grew land areas by 1000s of percents.
Gotta love that we have four "types" of municipalities with only one member each (I believe Bloomsburg is the only "town", incidentally--Scranton is the only Second Class A city).
Comparing Pittsburgh to Phoenix, Las Vegas, Houston and Jacksonville is like comparing an apple to a bowl of oranges. How much has Cleveland's land area grown in the last 100 years? Buffalo? Philadelphia? Boston? Hartford? Baltimore? Cincinnati? Detroit? Chicago? St. Louis? Milwaukee? Oh yeah...I think if somebody is going to insult other people's intelligence, they better have some intelligence of their own first. Until then, they're protesting too much when they accuse others of "retardation."
For what it is worth, I read that as "retardation" in the more general sense of a measure of the effects of delay, rather than in the specific mental sense.Anyway, comparing annexation histories really is a city by city thing, but it is also true that the City of Pittsburgh ended up occupying a well below average portion of its urbanized/metro area for a larger U.S. city. It is not quite at the bottom--that appears to be Miami by an analysis I once did. Other even smaller (proportionately) ones include Atlanta and Washington, although Washington is a pretty special case since it is constrained by the boundaries of the District of Columbia.
By the way, if you would like to imagine what a more typically-sized Pittsburgh would look like, it happens that adding together the CONNECT municipalities would put it in the middle range for large U.S. cities:http://www.connect.pitt.edu/About/Map.aspxAll of Allegheny County, on the other hand, would push it into the high end.All this is based on looking at the population of the area in question as a percentage of overall metro population. Pittsburgh is around 13%, the median for larger U.S. cities is more around 24%, CONNECT is about 29%, and Allegheny County is about 52%.Some others:Boston 14%Philadelphia 27%NYC 44%Baltimore 23%Cleveland 19%Columbus 43%Detroit 21%Buffalo 24%Miami 7% Atlanta 8% Hartford 10% Washington 11%San Antonio 62% Jacksonville 61% San Jose 52% Memphis 49% Indianapolis 47%
Few understand the impact of our fractured governance system. Imagine trying to build a factory in Allegheny Co that would employ 500 people. The permitting system requires traffic studies, utility usage, air and water quality impacts, storm water run off controls, and much more. You would need to deal with dozens of municipalities to get permission to widen roads, put in water, sewer, power, storm water management systems, and much more. Add in the authorities that have been created over the years that aren't part of that graphic. It would take 2-3 years to get all the permits. Or longer.Or you could go to a place that is all under just a couple government entities and open in less than a year. With way less costs involved.
DBR96A, time to stop speed reading for 'hot words' and appreciation to BrianTH for reading my "intelligent" comments in context.Also very interesting link there BrianTH, and yes if it sounds like I am only comparing 'sunbelt' cities, I'm not, just look at Indianapolis, Louisville (southern but not 'sunbelt') and Columbus OH among others.
15721meiqingpradaoakley sunglasses wholesalehollister clothinglouis vuitton handbagsreplica watcheskobe bryant shoes 2015christian louboutin saleburberry outletralph lauren outletlouboutin pas cherlouis vuittonchristian louboutin shoesfitflop shoeskate spademichael kors handbagsmichael kors outlettrue religion salenike air max ukmichael kors outlethollister cojordan 13true religioncoach outletmichael kors outletray ban glassesjordan 11 lowabercrombielouboutinlouis vuittoncoach factorty outletmichael kors handbagstoms shoesralph lauren outletmichael kors handbagstrue religion jeansray ban eyeglasseslouis vuitton handbagsmichael kors outletpolarized sunglassesjordan retro 3
20150721wanglilimichael kors outletmichael kors outlet onlinejuicy couture handbagspolo ralph laurenpolo outletmichael kors outletmichael kors outlet onlinepandora jewelrypandora ringsreb christian louboutinchristian louboutin shoesjordan retro 11jordan 11sjordan shoesair jordan shoesjordan shoesnew jordansjordan retro 11air jordan retrooakley sunglassesfake oakley sunglassescheap oakley sunglassesoakley sunglassesoakley vaultcheap oakley sunglassescheap oakleyscheap lebron james shoeskids lebron james shoeslebron james shoes 2015lebron 11kevin durant shoes 2015
2015929dongdongtoms outletCoach Outlet Discount Clearance Coach HandbagsGucci Outlet Store Locationsfootball jerseys cheapmichael kors outletAuthentic Louis Vuitton Bags DiscountOfficial Coach Online Factory Saleugg outlettrue religion outletray-ban sunglasses,ray ban sunglasses,ray bans,rayban,ray ban wayfarer,raybans,ray ban glasses,ray ban aviators,ray ban clubmaster,ray ban eyeglasses,cheap ray bans,ray bans sunglasses,ray ban aviator,ray bands,fake ray bans,ray ban prescription glasses,ray ban outlet,ray ban canada,ray ban sunglasses sale,ray ban saleNike Kobe Bryant Basketball Shoestory burch salelouis vuitton outlet storesChristian Louboutin Outlet Sale Cheap OnlineAuthentic Air Jordan 13 shoes for saleDesigner Louis Vuitton Handbags OutletAbercrombie and Fitch Storecoach outletMichael Kors Factory Outlet Online OfficialLouis vuitton Official Website Outlet OnlineJordan Concords Low And HighJordan 3 Retro 2015canada goose saleNew Michael Kors Handbags Outlet Onlinenike air max 90Louis Vuitton Clearance Salehermes outletlouis vuitton handbagsOakley Polarized Sunglasses Cheap Outlet Storecheap uggs
chenlina20151208gucci outletreplica watchesadidas superstarscoach factory outlet onlineuggs outletugg australialongchamp outletlouis vuitton handbagsmichael kors handbagscoach outlet store onlineugg bootsuggs on salepolo ralph lauren outletugg outletugg bootsray ban sunglasses outletlouis vuitton handbagsoakley sunglasses cheapkids lebron shoescheap uggscheap jordan shoesuggs for mennike trainers ukuggs bootsmichael kors outletuggs on salecheap uggsray ban sunglassescoach factory outletcheap oakley sunglassesoakley sunglasses cheapray ban sunglassesugg boots for womentory burch outletcanada goose outletabercrombiepolo ralph laurenmichael kors outlet onlinekevin durant basketball shoesair force 1as
zhengjx20160518nike uklebron 13coach factory outletmont blanc pencheap tomsnike blazers shoesmichael kors outletbeats by dre outletralph lauren outletray ban sunglassesmichael kors outlethollister clothingoakley vaulttrue religion outlet onlinelouis vuitton handbagsralph lauren saletimberlandsmichael kors outletbasketball shoesgucci outletlouis vuitton pursesoakley outletcoach outletkate spade outletair jordan shoescoach outletlebron 12oakley sunglasseskate spade handbagsed hardy outletcheap oakley sunglassesair jordan femmelebron 12nike store uklouis vuitton outletmichael kors outletcoach factory outletray ban sunglassescoach outletoakley outlet
ghd hair straightenerslouis vuitton handbagsretro jordans 13adidas stan smithcoach factory outlet onlineair jordan shoesabercrombie clothingcoach outletcoach factory outletcoach outlet onlinekate spade outlethermes birkin handbagsray ban sonnenbrilletoms shoescoach outlet store online clearancesmont blanc pens outletlouis vuitton outlet onlinecoach factory outlet onlineray ban outletlouis vuitton outletlebron 13air jordan 8rolex watchescoach outlet clearancelouis vuitton pursescoach factory outletray banscoach outlet store online clearancesadidas nmdcoach outletcheap ray ban sunglassespolo ralph laurensupra shoesair jordan 4oakley outletmichael kors outlet clearancemichael kors purseschristian louboutin outletcoach outlet onlineburberry sale20168.9chenjinyan
Post a Comment
Create a Link
This work by Christopher Briem is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States License.
Your less than random
That which was: Pittsblog 2.0
Null Space en español
or Null Space на русском
Tweets by @chrisbriem
New: Travel and Transit
Did you know the G20 came to Pittsburgh?
My Manyeyes Visualizations
This work by Chris Briem is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 United States License.